Inspect the potato plant's vine after it flowers. Harvest the potato from the ground when the vine dies and turns brown. Remove the potato from the ground with a spade fork.
Remove an Irish potato from the ground when it reaches about 2 to 3 inches in diameter, and remove a new potato when it reaches 1 1/4 to 1 1/2 inches in diameter.
Inspect the potato for "eyes." Potato eyes grow as new sprouts. The sprouts indicate that the potato may have sat around for a while and its quality has diminished.
Look for green spots on the potato. When a potato is exposed to the sun, the potato forms green spots that cause the potato to taste bitter. These spots are toxic when consumed in large amounts.
Examine the potato for bruises, discolorations and cuts. Avoid using a damaged potato. Select only a potato that has a smooth surface.