Fill a nursery tray with sterile seed-starting compost. Spray the compost liberally with water using a spray bottle to settle it and remove any trapped air.
Spread the tiny, hairy bachelor button seeds 1 inch apart across the surface of the seed-starting compost. Cover the seeds with a 1/4-inch-thick layer of seed-starting compost.
Spray the top layer of seed-starting compost using the spray bottle until it feels saturated. Maintain moisture in the top 3/4-inch of the seed-starting compost during the germination process.
Place the nursery tray on a greenhouse warming mat set to 68 degrees Fahrenheit near a source of bright light, such as under a large window or outdoors in a cold frame.
Watch for sprouting in seven to 14 days. Transplant the bachelor button seedlings into 4-inch pots filled with potting soil once they reach 1-inch in height.
Keep the bachelor button seedlings in their starter pots for one month so they can establish a healthy root system before transplanting them into a permanent container or bed in late spring.