Differences Between Above Ground & Inground Swimming Pools

Cost and Home Value

• Above ground pools are generally more cost-effective during the build phase and over the life of the pool. In-ground pools require not only the construction of the pool, but also the digging and preparation of the site. The materials needed for an in-ground pool are typically much more permanent, need to be much stronger and are much more expensive. The combination of labor and materials for an above ground pool can be up to 10 times less than that of an inground pool.

  An in-ground pool is also a more permanent structure, and building this on the property can lead to an increase in the assessed value of the home and, in turn, to the property taxes. While it can raise the value of the home, it can also make the home more difficult to sell if prospective buyers aren't interested in a pool. Above ground pools are not permanent structures and can easily be dismantled.

Features

• Above ground pools are usually the same depth throughout the entire pool, while in-ground pools can easily be constructed with a shallow end and a deep end. While the standard depth of an above ground pool is 4 feet, the deep end of an in-ground pool can be anywhere from 6 to 12 feet. This adds flexibility to the pool, allowing in-ground pool owners to install diving boards, slides and other features that could not be safely included in a shallower pool. An in-ground pool can be dug to almost any shape and size, while the building of an above ground pool is limited by structural constraints.

Maintenance

• Above ground pools usually have less maintenance associated with their upkeep. In-ground pools will quickly fill with debris such as grass clipping, leaves and dirt, while the sides of the above ground pool offer some protection from debris blowing into the water. The shapes and uneven bottom of the inground pool can make it more difficult to vacuum, and if the pool is too large, reaching the center to clean it from the edge might not be possible. In-ground pools typically hold more water than an above ground pool, meaning that more chemicals are needed to treat the pool. A higher chemical consumption means higher operating costs than an above ground pool.

Safety

• The difference in safety between the two types of pools can be a major concern, especially for families with small children and pets. It is easier to keep unwanted swimmers out of an above ground pool, as they are usually equipped with a ladder that can be removed or tied up. It is extremely easy for a child or pet to wander into an in-ground pool, and when these pools have a solar cover on, the results can be devastating. Pool alarms are available but not foolproof, and for those who choose an in-ground pool over an above ground for the aesthetic factor, installing a security fence can eliminate the advantages.