Sprinkle cornstarch over the black eye makeup stains to absorb oil. Allow the cornstarch to remain on the wood surface for 15 minutes. Wipe the cornstarch off the wood furniture with a paper towel.
Fill a bucket with 1/2 gallon of warm water. Add 1 teaspoon of dishwashing detergent to the water.
Wet a clean cloth with the diluted detergent solution. Squeeze out the cloth to remove excess moisture.
Wipe the wood furniture to remove the remaining black eye makeup from the surface. Rinse the cloth as you remove the makeup stain. Add more detergent solution and continue to scrub.
Rinse the wood surface by wiping it off with a damp cloth. Dry the wood with another cloth.
Treat any remaining discoloration and grease stain from the black eye makeup with a poultice. Place 1 tablespoon of Fuller's Earth and 1 1/2 tablespoons of dry cleaning solvent in a bowl. Stir the two ingredients to create a stain-absorbing paste.
Smooth the paste over any remaining black eye makeup stain. Allow the paste to dry. Wipe the dried paste off with a damp cloth. Clean the wood with the detergent mixture to remove any poultice paste residue.
Rinse the wood with a damp cloth. Dry the surface with another clean cloth.