Adhesive backed shelf papers can cause about as many problems as they solve. Their sticky surfaces are tricky to apply, the adhesive can off-gas fumes into your drawers and some pests, such as cockroaches, enjoy feasting on the glue. Over time, the adhesive can become so firmly attached to your drawer's surface that the attached paper is nearly impossible to remove and leaves behind a damaged, sticky residue-covered drawer. Removable liners, while often a pricier option, avoid these issues and allow you to change your shelf paper at your whim or bring them with you if you move.
The less objects that roll around inside your drawers, the easier keeping your drawers organized will be. Look for removable shelf papers with flattened ridges or ribs instead of the spongy popcorn texture, which tends to shift. The flatter surface grips better to the drawer's bottom and provides a more stable surface for resting objects. If you'd rather use a completely flat surface, opt for cork shelf liner. Cork is mildew resistant, soft, and, like ridged shelf paper, grips well on both sides.
If your decorating budget is limited to more visible improvements, you don't need to forsake lining your shelves. Line your shelves with paper or fabric you have available from other projects as long as the leftover material is large enough, water resistant and wipes clean. Fabrics up to the task include oil cloth, sturdy felt and general outdoor fabrics. If you're lining a drawer to protect the contents from the acid emitted by wood, only use leftover papers and materials you're sure are acid-free, or you increase the risk of acid damage to your drawers' contents. Use a small square of acid-free, double-sided tape to hold your DIY liner in place at the corners.
Shelf paper protects wooden shelves' unfinished porous or chipable painted surfaces from damage such as moisture, bacteria and staining. Most new shelves are constructed from sealed wood, particle board or medium-density fiberboard (MDF). These construction materials, especially when covered by a laminate surface, aren't as porous as unfinished wood and are wipeable, which makes installing shelf paper unnecessary.