Remove the diverter’s handle. The handle is secured to the diverter with a single screw located in the middle of the handle. If the screw is not visible, it is concealed behind a plastic cap. Lift the cap away from the handle with a standard screwdriver to reveal the screw. Remove the screw with a Phillips screwdriver and pull the handle off the diverter.
Remove the screws that secure the escutcheon plate to the shower wall with a Phillips screwdriver. Pull the plate away from the wall to reveal a large bonnet nut.
Turn the bonnet nut in a counterclockwise direction with a wrench until it detaches from the diverter.
Remove the diverter valve. The valve features a retaining nut at its base designed to accommodate a socket. Turn the valve in a counterclockwise direction with a socket wrench until the diverter detaches from the water pipe, then slide the diverter out of the wall.
Remove the brass screw on the bottom of the diverter with the Phillips screwdriver. The screw secures a rubber washer to the diverter. Slide the washer off the screw after removing the screw.
Unscrew the threaded spindle from the retaining nut and slide the spindle out of the nut. The spindle is the shaft that runs through the center of the retaining nut.
Slide the plastic washer off the threaded spindle.