Spray paint the wooden handle of a brand new plunger. Allow it to dry overnight and apply another coat of spray paint, if you like.
Cut a piece of thick, soft fabric in a color that matches your bathroom decor into a 12-inch square. Materials such as velvet, velour, terry cloth or flannel are appropriate.
Place the square of fabric on a flat surface. Set the rubber end of the plunger directly onto the center of it. Pull up the sides of the fabric around the plunger, holding it at the base.
Wrap a rubber band around the bunched up fabric at the base of the plunger to hold it all together. Trim off the excess fabric.
Cut a 12-inch piece of ribbon and wrap it around the rubber band to cover it. Tie a festive bow. Place your spools of toilet paper onto the wooden handle in a neat stack.