Install paneling on the wall around the fireplace. If you have space, consider building in some cupboards into the paneling for authenticity.
Line the paneling with molding. The most popular molding designs were plain (for poorer homes) and carved fruit, flowers and images of Aesop’s fables for wealthier homes.
Paint the paneling a bright color. Common colors include deep yellow, minty green, cottage blue or bright red.
Set some colonial artifacts such as antique bowls, vases or plates out on the mantle of the fireplace.
Hang a family portrait over your mantle. Order a canvas print of a photo to give the picture a more antique feel.