Irrigate the lawn to moisten the first 6 inches of top soil the day before applying a herbicide, as recommended by the Purdue Turfgrass Program. You can that tell the water has reached 6 inches by digging a 6-inch hole and feeling the bottom to see if it is moist. Water the lawn in the morning. Wet grass blades and nighttime temperatures encourage lawn fungal diseases.
Apply a herbicide that contains methanearsonate. Coat the yellow nutsedge evenly with the herbicide, according to the herbicide's directions.
Water the lawn two days after applying the herbicide to a soil depth of 6 inches. Reapply the herbicide in a week. You may have to repeat the herbicide applications to completely eradicate the yellow nutsedge from your lawn.
Dip a small paint brush into a broad-spectrum herbicide that contains glyphosate. Apply the herbicide to the blades of the young yellow nutsedge growing next to ornamental plants. Be careful not to apply the herbicide to the ornamental plants, because glyphosate kills off everything it comes in contact with.
Reapply the broad-spectrum herbicide in two to three days to remove the rest of the growing yellow nutsedge.