Pillow-Top Mattress vs. Memory Foam

Thickness

• Pillow-top mattresses, because they have an extra layer over the surface that creates the plush, pillow-type effect, are generally thicker than memory foam mattresses. However, some pillow-top mattresses are not as high-quality and may be similar in thickness to memory foam. Memory foam mattresses are denser, so the user is supported by the weight of the material, not air and springs.

Cost

• In most places, memory foam mattresses are more expensive than pillow-top mattresses. However, they will need to be replaced less frequently than a pillow-top mattress. So, while you may be paying more upfront, it can actually save you money in the long run. When choosing the right mattress for your needs, this initial investment and your budget should be a consideration.

Types

• Each type of mattress has its own variations. For example, a pillow-top mattress comes in various thicknesses. Pillow-top mattress have quilted covers, sometimes made with cotton or synthetic blends. Like pillow-top styles, memory foam mattresses are made by a number of manufacturers.

Temperature Sensitivity

• Memory foam mattresses are temperature-sensitive. To work correctly and mold to the comfort of the owner, warmer temperatures are required. The colder the room the bed is placed in, the firmer and more viscous it is. This has to do with the elasticity in the material. Pillow-top mattresses are not temperature-sensitive, functioning the same in any environment.

Comfort

• When purchasing a mattress, it is truly a matter of preference. For those who appreciate a soft bed, pillow-top mattresses can be an ideal fit. Memory foam is not quite firm once it is broken it, but it is not as soft as a pillow-top. Instead of being soft, it forms to your shape, which can take some of the stress off your body caused by sleeping on an unsupportive mattress. Memory foam mattresses take some time to mold and fit your form, so the level of comfort might not be fully attained for several weeks.