Remove the door from its hinges and take off any hardware, such as the doorknob. Set the hardware aside and place the door in a well-ventilated work space.
Strip the original finish using mineral spirits or other finish-stripping solvent. Wipe the solvent on the door with a clean cloth and allow the solvent to soak for about five minutes before wiping the door clean. Apply more solvent as necessary.
Wash the door with hot, soapy water and a fresh cloth. Rinse the door thoroughly and allow it to dry. Prop it up and let it sit at an angle to help it dry faster.
Rub a gel-type oil stain into the grain of the fiberglass with a clean cloth. Since this is a wood-look door, it will have its own grain. Always work with the grain when applying stain and sealers. Wipe away the excess stain with a clean cloth.
Let the stain dry into the fiberglass. Once the stain is completely dry, you can apply a protective topcoat, such as polyurethane. Mix the polyurethane carefully, then pour a small amount in a bucket.
Spread the polyurethane over the fiberglass door with a foam or lamb's wool applicator. As with the stain, the polyurethane must be applied with the grain. Allow the polyurethane to dry, then apply a second coat in the same fashion before reassembling the door.