Dimensional Shingles Vs. Metal Roofing

Dimensional Shingle vs. Metal

• Dimensional shingles are a type of asphalt shingle that is specially designed to resemble a wood shingle or shake. They are produced with a heavier foundation than standard asphalt, making them more durable and longer lasting than older versions. Metal roofing comes in a wide variety of materials, including copper, steel, aluminum and zinc. These types of shingles are frequently produced using recycled metal, and are recyclable, making them among the most eco-friendly options on the market.

Lifespan

• The lifespan of any roof will vary depending on local weather conditions. It is essential to do research prior to making any roofing selection, particularly in areas with extreme temperatures, snow or high sun exposure. Most dimensional shingles come with a 30 year lifespan, which is an improvement over the standard asphalt shingle that carries a 15 to 20 year lifespan. Metal roofing, no matter the type of metal, is perhaps the longest lasting material on the market. According to copperroofing.net, a metal roof will last as long as 100 years.

Cost

• With most types of roofing, the longer the lifespan, the higher the cost. The cost of dimensional shingles will vary a little bit, but homeowners should plan to spend between $50 and $150 per square foot as of September 2011. Metal has a fairly wide range of price options, but most will run between two and three times the cost of asphalt. This higher price is due primarily to the longer life expectancy of the material.

Weather Conditions

• Both standard and dimensional asphalt shingles are an ideal choice for most parts of the country. They will hold up against harsh weather including sun, heat, rain and snow with little maintenance. The thicker nature of the dimensional shingle makes it more fire resistant than standard asphalt. This newer manufacturing also increases the aesthetic of the dimensional shingle, making it look more like a natural or artificial wood shingle. Metal roofing is resistant to most types of harsh weather, high winds, rain and snow. Additionally, it won’t warp or crack like asphalt and requires little maintenance to remain in good condition.